05 March 2018
Munich
Reporter: Barney Dixon

SUEPO blasts EPO employment proposal


The Staff Union of the European Patent Office (SUEPO) has blasted recent proposals to the employment framework of the office, arguing that the trust of its staff in its management and administrative council has been lost.

The employment proposals are part of the “extreme” situation at the office, that Union Syndicale Fédérale highlighted in a recent letter.

Brought by EPO president Benoît Battistelli and principal director of human resources, Elodie Bergot, the proposals were criticised by the office’s Central Staff Committee for being “far-reaching”.

Article 53(1)(f) of the proposal would have given the EPO the ability to terminate the service of an employee if the “exigencies of the service require abolition of their post or a reduction in staff”.

However, at the end of February, the proposal was halted and the article was withdrawn.

In a letter to its members, SUEPO said that the original proposal generated “a great turmoil among staff”.

It added: “Trust in management is gone. The few souls who were still putting some trust in EPO management have had a rude awakening.

“Bergot and Battistelli have just demonstrated that staff cannot rely on the office respecting even the most sacred aspects of their working conditions.”

“Trust in the administrative council is gone. This time, the board 28 has dared to resist an (outgoing) President and blocked article 53(1)(f), but what will happen next time crazy ideas are pushed by the EPO management? By now, the Administrative Council has built the (deserved) reputation of being fickle and weak, unable or unwilling to supervise efficiently the office.”

SUEPO also argued that staff’s trust in justice has been lost, stating: “As for the incredibly slow EPO “justice” system, it is structurally and politically unable to defend staff’s most basic rights. What is the point in being proven right five to ten years after your boss has grossly misbehaved, for example by unlawfully terminating your ‘permanent’ employment unilaterally?”

The union also highlighted a communique from Battistelli, in which he claimed that he had convinced the administrative council to abandon article 53(1)(f).

Battistelli said: “In any event, I understood that it caused of great deal of [sic] concerns among the staff and this is why I have convinced the [administrative council] during its second meeting on [21 February] to abandon it.”

Despite the removal of article 53(1)(f), SUEPO said that the current version of the proposal is still not acceptable, “as it contains many objectionable changes (like the possibility to hire EPO staff under 5-years contract for a total duration of 10 years before possibly becoming ‘permanent’)”.

It added: “In any event, the episode is significant for its effect on the EPO community. The words of article 53(1)(f) will not be in our Codex, but are engraved in everybody’s mind.”

More Europe news
The latest news from IPPro Patents
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
UK will explore staying in the UPC post-Brexit
12 July 2018 | London | Reporter: Ben Wodecki
The UK will explore options on intellectual property “including participation in the Unified Patent Court and unitary patent system” as part of the Brexit deal, according to a new white paper from the UK government
China cracks top 20 in Global Innovation Index
10 July 2018 | Geneva | Reporter: Ben Wodecki
China has broken into the top 20 most innovative economies with Switzerland retaining its number one spot in the Global Innovation Index (GII)
Marks & Clerk promotes four to partner
10 July 2018 | London | Reporter: Ben Wodecki
Marks and Clerk has promoted Matthijs Branderhorst, Mash-Hud Iqbal, David Grant, and Thomas Zvesper as partner in four of its offices in the UK
European Commission seeks SEP group members
06 July 2018 | Brussels | Reporter: Ben Wodecki
The European Commission has set up a group to consider licensing and valuations of standard-essential patents
Staff engagement ‘top priority’ of new EPO president
04 July 2018 | Munich | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Staff engagement is among new European Patent Office president António Campinos’s “top priorities”, according to a message on the EPO website
Campinos begins EPO tenure
02 July 2018 | Munich | Reporter: Barney Dixon
António Campinos has officially begun his five-year term as president of the European Patent Office
EPO and CIPC reinforced co-operation programme
02 July 2018 | Munich | Reporter: Ben Wodecki
The European Patent Office and South Africa’s Companies and Intellectual Property Commission have signed a reinforced co-operation agreement