08 September 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Kraft loses cookie patent appeal

Intercontinental Great Brands’s (formerly Kraft Foods) patent for cookie packaging is invalid, according to a new ruling from the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

Kraft brought a case against Kellogg’s in 2013, alleging that Kellogg’s had used resealable packages that circumvent the Kraft patent while maintaining similar properties.

The US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois found the patent to be obvious and held that Kellogg’s was entitled to a summary judgement of invalidity.

But the court also held that Kraft was entitled to a summary judgement rejecting a counterclaim for unenforceability.

Both parties appealed to the Federal Circuit, which upheld the lower court’s decision, invalidating the Kraft patent.

In its ruling, the Federal Circuit said that Kraft’s evidence of “commercial success tied to the patent-claimed packaging, industry praise, and copying by Kellogg’s”, could not overcome the obviousness of the patent.

However, Judge Jimmie Reyna dissented from the majority, arguing that the court had “turned a blind eye to what I consider to be a grave concern: the application of a prima facie test that necessarily achieves a legal determination of obviousness prior to full and fair consideration of evidence of objective indicia of nonobviousness”.

He said: “There should be no prima facie rule or test in the obviousness inquiry. Stated differently, the burden of persuasion should not shift from the challenger to the patent holder after a legal determination of obviousness has already been made.”

More news
The latest news from IPPro Patents
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Ex-Oblon attorneys start own patent firm
22 September 2017 | Virginia | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Ex-Oblon attorneys Kirsten Grüneberg and Eric Myers have launched their own patent boutique law firm in Virginia
Red Hat expands Patent Promise
22 September 2017 | Raleigh | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Open-source software provider Red Hat has revised its Patent Promise, which was initially intended to discourage patent aggression against free and open-source software
Google and HTC sign $1.1 billion deal
21 September 2017 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Google and HTC have signed a $1.1 billion agreement that will net Google a portion of HTC’s smartphone research and development team and a separate non-exclusive intellectual property license
IP Awareness Summit to be held in November
20 September 2017 | Chicago | Reporter: Barney Dixon
The Centre for Intellectual Property Understanding, alongside the Chicago-Kent College of Law, will be holding the first Intellectual Property Awareness Summit in Chicago on 6 November
Motorola wins direct infringement challenge
20 September 2017 | Washington DC | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Motorola has won its direct patent infringement appeal against Intellectual Ventures, but failed to secure an invalidity ruling
Dali and Fiplex settle down
19 September 2017 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Dali Wireless has settled with Fiplex Communications over patents for its Public Safety distributed antenna systems (DAS) products
Nokia and LG complete arbitration
18 September 2017 | Espoo | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Nokia and LG Electronics have finally settled their patent licence dispute at the International Court of Arbitration