03 July 2017
Ottawa
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Canadian Supreme Court rips up promise doctrine


The Canadian Supreme Court has ripped up the country’s controversial ‘promise doctrine’ and upheld AstraZeneca’s heartburn drug patent as valid in its case against Apotex.

Apotex attempted to sell a generic version of AstraZeneca’s heartburn drug, Nexium, to which AstraZeneca responded with a patent infringement lawsuit.

Canada’s Federal Court of Appeals held that AstraZeneca’s patent for the drug was “invalid for lack of utility because, applying the promise of the patent doctrine, it promised more than it could provide”.

The dispute then went to the Supreme Court, which ruled that the promise doctrine is “not the correct method of determining whether the utility requirement under Section 2 of the Canadian Patent Act is met”.

“The promise doctrine is incongruent with both the words and the scheme of the Patent Act.”

The US Chamber of Commerce’s Global Intellectual Property Center (GIPC) welcomed the decision, with vice president of international intellectual property policy, Patrick Kilbride, describing the “restrictive approach” of the doctrine as “making it difficult to obtain or defend a life sciences patents in Canada”.

“Today, the Supreme Court has begun to restore much-needed clarity and confidence that biopharmaceutical innovators will be afforded equal protections under the law,” he said. “This ruling sends an important signal that Canada is open for the business of innovation.”

According to the GIPC, since the creation of the promise doctrine in 2005, 26 patents that covered 22 innovative medicines have been overturned.

Earlier this year, Eli Lilly lost its North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) dispute with Canada over the doctrine.

Eli Lilly claimed that the doctrine contravened Canada’s NAFTA obligations, but a panel said it didn’t amount to a denial of justice warranting investor-state arbitration.

At the time, Kilbride said the doctrine “dramatically undermines legal certainty for medical innovators in Canada”.

More news
The latest news from IPPro Patents
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Countries should break IP rules to ensure growth, says report
23 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Countries such as India and China should break harmonised intellectual property rules to avoid protectionist measures from the US and EU, according to a new report from Gowling WLG
EPO employment proposal halted
22 February 2018 | Munich | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A proposal to scrap permanent employment contracts at the EPO has been halted and a controversial article within it withdrawn, a source close to the Staff Union of the EPO has confirmed
UPC complaint to be heard in 2018
22 February 2018 | Karlsruhe | Reporter: Barney Dixon
The German Federal Constitutional Court will hear the constitutional complaint against the UPC in 2018
Cabinet Plasseraud promotes four to partner
21 February 2018 | Paris | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Cabinet Plasseraud has appointed for intellectual property attorneys to partner
NPE litigation in Europe sees continued growth
20 February 2018 | Brussels | Reporter: Barney Dixon
NPE litigation and enforcement in Europe has increased by an average almost 20 percent year-on-year since 2007, according to a new report from Darts-IP
BakerHostetler hires IP partner
19 February 2018 | Los Angeles | Reporter: Barney Dixon
BakerHostetler has hired Troy Schmelzer as partner in its intellectual property group
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton promotes four to partner
16 February 2018 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton has promoted four intellectual property attorneys to partner across its Shanghai, San Diego and San Francisco offices