09 May 2017
Virginia
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Intellectual Ventures loses patents in Ericsson appeal


The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has backed the invalidation of two Intellectual Ventures patents.

The Federal Circuit upheld Ericsson’s successful inter-partes review proceedings on 8 May, following the Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB) decision to find them obvious.

The patents protected a method for selection of appropriate bandwidth in a multi-bandwidth communication system.

The PTAB ruled on 25 August 2015 that the patents fell foul of a patent covering a system using orthogonal frequency division multiplexing.

On appeal, Intellectual Ventures argued that the PTAB had “misconstrued two claim terms” to mean something no party argued for or expected.

The PTAB acted contrary to Federal Circuit decisions in Magnum Oil and SAS, which held that “the [PTAB] must base its decision on arguments that were advanced by a party, and to which the opposing party was given a chance to respond”.

The PTAB ignored its proposed construction and adopting one in its final written decision that no party previously advanced.

The Federal Circuit found “no due process violation” and “the board’s claim construction was correct”.

“The record demonstrates that Intellectual Ventures had notice and an opportunity to be heard … After the board issued its final written decision, Intellectual Ventures was entitled to seek a rehearing. It did not.”

“In Magnum Oil, the board supplied completely new arguments that the petitioner never raised. Not so here, where the Board questioned counsel extensively over the construction of ‘an indication of an operating bandwidth’ after receiving briefs that contested both whether and how the PTAB needed to construe the term.”

“The PTAB is not constrained by the parties’ proposed constructions and is free to adopt its own construction, as it did here.”

More news
The latest news from IPPro Patents
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Countries should break IP rules to ensure growth, says report
23 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Countries such as India and China should break harmonised intellectual property rules to avoid protectionist measures from the US and EU, according to a new report from Gowling WLG
EPO employment proposal halted
22 February 2018 | Munich | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A proposal to scrap permanent employment contracts at the EPO has been halted and a controversial article within it withdrawn, a source close to the Staff Union of the EPO has confirmed
UPC complaint to be heard in 2018
22 February 2018 | Karlsruhe | Reporter: Barney Dixon
The German Federal Constitutional Court will hear the constitutional complaint against the UPC in 2018
Cabinet Plasseraud promotes four to partner
21 February 2018 | Paris | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Cabinet Plasseraud has appointed for intellectual property attorneys to partner
NPE litigation in Europe sees continued growth
20 February 2018 | Brussels | Reporter: Barney Dixon
NPE litigation and enforcement in Europe has increased by an average almost 20 percent year-on-year since 2007, according to a new report from Darts-IP
BakerHostetler hires IP partner
19 February 2018 | Los Angeles | Reporter: Barney Dixon
BakerHostetler has hired Troy Schmelzer as partner in its intellectual property group
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton promotes four to partner
16 February 2018 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton has promoted four intellectual property attorneys to partner across its Shanghai, San Diego and San Francisco offices